Perhaps. Of course, if you kick deep, there is no guarantee that the kick won't be run back for a touchdown or back to midfield or more. You're down by 3 points with 2 minutes left...everything at that point has risks and rewards. That's my point.
That's true. Still more likely to have them start at the 20, but nonetheless, the risk is there.
No team is going to attempt a 50 yard field goal in that situation. Witness...the NY Jets.
Just false. Like I said, if the receiving team gets any kind of yards on its 3 and out drive (or if the kick doesn't go 10 yards), it wouldn't even be a 50 yarder. It'd be a 40+ yarder. Just because the Jets weren't in that position (and have Jay Feeley as their kicker), it doesn't mean other teams with a more trustworthy kicker wouldn't take a 41 yarder to go up two scores.
This makes no sense at all. If the Chargers recover the onsides kick and doesn't score, the game is over. The Jets don't need to go for anything, much less 65 yards for a touchdown.
How does that not make sense? You don't agree going 65+ yards for a score is harder than going 20 yards?
But if you recover the onsides kick, you get the ball back and don't have to stop them at all. You seem to misunderstand the purpose of the onsides kick...it's not to get in the best position for your defense to get a stop. It's so you don't have to play defense at all.
No need to be d-baggy. Yes. I do understand the purpose of the onsides kick. And I also know they are successful anywhere from 18-26%, depending what source you look at. I agree, you've got to weigh the risks and benefits. But they were down 3 points, not multiple scores. Making the other team go three and out puts you in position to win. Down by more, sometimes you
have to onside kick it, which is a position the Chargers were not in. Especially considering that their defense is good, and really had not played badly all game.
I understand the whole point of an onsides is to get the ball back,not field position. But when you are down with a FG and that much time left, just don't think its the right time. To each their own though. Like I've said before, I'm not an NFL coach, just an guy with a remote and cheetos on the couch.