I think this is where Luhnow is at if we make go for him. Contractually, it would have to be less years, opt outs, and a new project for BH that he might find interesting --- he can do one more dog and pony FA show and end his career in a new locale.
And in terms of his inconsistency, I am not sure there is another left handed power hitting influence that could plug into our team with his experience and performance. Some might say Kyle Tucker, and he certainly projects well, but there is just as much if not more risk in a Tucker/Reddick platoon than a Harper buy.
Rose colored glasses? Definitely. Agree he is wild card. But a G Stanton like mess? Not in my book.
Thanks for the replies though - I enjoy counter arguments.
Actually - and this surprised me a little - Giancarlo and ol' Bryce are pretty comparable players overall. Stanton has been around longer, but just taking the last 5 years, 2014-18:
Stanton: 24.4 WAR, 20.9 oWAR, 148 OPS+, 2,823 PA, .270/.360/.557 with 188 HR, 478 RBI
Harper: 18.6 WAR, 20.6 oWAR, 144 OPS+, 2,863 PA, .282/.401/.525 with 142 HR, 404 RBI
And Stanton didn't have a
bad year with the Yankees, just not his typical outstanding year: 38 HR, 100 RBI, 126 OPS+
One other quibble, if I may: opt-outs favor the player. If Harper gets an opt-out it's a safety net for him, not the team. And I could be wrong, but I don't think he will sign any kind of shorter-term guarantee like you're talking about.
I think Brantley will bring some balance to the lineup - he crushes RHP. And Altuve hits everyone, Bregman too. Maybe by 2020 Tucker and Alvarez will also be LH power threats.