That Yankees lineup would have been mighty fearsome in 2004. Overbay hit .301 with 53 doubles, Hafner hit .311 with 28 dingers and 109 RBI, Wells was coming off 2 straight 100-RBI seasons and about to win his first Gold Glove, and Pettitte was coming off a season where he won 21 games and finished 6th in CY voting.
I'll say one thing, though: Ol' Andy sure has found the fountain of youth. Yessir...