I was always more partial to Baseball Stars, the one that let you pick teams like "The Lovely Ladies" and the "Ghastly Monsters." You could create your own team, too. I remember getting into big trouble when I rented it and whoever had the game last named their team "The Fuckers." My parents ran in from the other room to find out why I was laughing my 9-year-old ass off. Then they wouldn't believe me when I told them it was someone else that made the obscene team name.
And what was that game that had the robot baseball players that could shoot each other with missiles and fireballs and stuff? Those guys anticipated the post-steroid Barry Bonds like 10 years before it happened!