Don't forget that Bedard is under club control for 2 seasons (vs. one for Santana) and will be cheaper for the first season and probably the 2nd as well. That adds value to Bedard.
True, but Santanna has a MUCH better track record of success. Bedard basically broke through last year. Santanna has been doing his best "Best Pitcher in Baseball" trick for 3+ years.
But I do understand where you are comming from, still think Minn got the short end of the stick. But from what I have heard that is more because they got too greedy, and should have taken some of the earlier offers. If you believe the rumor the Red Sox had at one time the best offer on the table, but pulled it off because the Twins asked for more.