DEEP THOUGHTS!
Could you drill down on that last point for me, Noe. Of what would that kind of statement be an an indication? Aging? Weak-mindedness? Mound issues? A hiddent desire to be on Dancing with the Stars? Painful rectal itch (if so, either get him some Blue Star or perhaps that new stuff Shimmy, which doubles as a dessert topping for his lard ass)? Pining for the cool, thin air of Denver?
All silliness aside, how broadly should one interpret a "haven't felt in rhythm" remark? Nothing more than his being evasive?
Actually, it's pretty common pitcher speak to say "I haven't lost anything, I just need time to get there!". Say you're Roger Clemens and want to pitch in May. You don't have the luxury of breaking down your arm in spring training like other pitchers. So you do the best you can and realize along the way you won't feel in rhythm to pitch the way you know you can eventually.
Apparently JJ feels he lost rhythm with his time off to let the elbow heal and just has not felt all the way back yet. If he's right, it's just a matter of time before he's performing well. But at some point, you look at the things happening on the field and you just have to approach a player about being hurt.
Lance Berkman had a terrible start to the season. We all said it was just a matter of time for Berkman to start hitting. But little things in his swing kept gnawing at us all that there may be more to it... like injury. We know about the hand now but who knows if it's been barking at him all season long or if it's just a recently development that has hindered him recently.
So juneberno with these things, but you have to ask just in case. Ensberg hid his injury from the team last year but ultimately it got him benched because he kept saying he was fine when he wasn't and the shoulder was giving him fits.