Looking at the situational stuff, he gets whacked around pretty good when the game is tied, both last year and this year. It's all real small sample sizes, but he's essentially the same pitcher as last year except for the home runs. Even the batting average on balls in play is down this year. I think he's not so much a scapegoat as a guy not suited to the role - like Happ says, he's not the guy in a high-leverage situation, especially one that calls for ground ball outs.