Star - Wandy. Extremely dependable, and a great ERA. Backed by a more dependable offense, he might have had 17-18 wins.
Spike - 1/2 vote to Miggy, 1/2 vote to Bourn. To me, the Spike award should go to somebody who plays damn near every day and puts up great numbers in spite of the nicks and bruises, and comes up with the clutch play that saves a game or ignites the team. Miggy had numerous clutch hits, and I shudder to think how much worse the swoon would have been without his competitive attitude. Bourn seemed to make two or three amazing catches every week, and without him in CF the pitching staff would have been cover-your-eyes bad, plus he became a legitimate lead-off man.