I don't see Tucker getting any time at DH. Others, yes, not Tucker. But even with the win-now major league option the Astros will employ, I don't agree that spending part or all of the season (which I don't envision will happen... re: all of the season) in AAA is a retardation of Tucker's development. If anything, last season proved he wasn't ready. He didn't prove he was ready to displace Reddick this spring either. Marisnick is the quality fourth outfielder and Kemp is a good left handed outfielder type that can use his versatility to help the club in many different ways. Tucker needs ABs as an every day outfielder. Period. If not in the majors now, then eventually. RIght now, he can find his starter ABs in AAA, which is fine for a 22 year old.
I agree completely that Kemp and Marisnick deserve to be on the MLB roster and Tucker needs consistent at bats, so getting them in AAA is better than riding the pine in the majors. I also agree that he proved he wasn’t ready when he got his chance last year, so a little more minor-league seasoning won’t hurt him. However, the pitchers he’s going to face in AAA aren’t as good as those in the major leagues, and he hit .332/.400/.590 in AAA last year. So Hinch is dead on that it’s the subtleties that Tucker needs to work on, whether it’s plate discipline, defense, baserunning, or his overall approach at the plate.
Also, I agree that Tucker wouldn’t play DH if he platooned with White at some point in the season. More likely, he would start in the outfield with one of the Astros’ regular outfielders getting the nod at DH that day.