I've only pitched a handful of times, but my greatest performance may have been picking a guy off at 1B. There were runners at 1B and 2B (tying and winning runs, with 2 out in the 9th), and the first baseman was playing behind the runner at 1B. Between pitches, the first baseman gives me "the look". As I take the stretch, I'm looking back at the runner at 2B. And all I'm telling myself is "don't look at 1B...don't look at 1B". Well, we timed it just right, and the first baseman darted in behind the runner, just as I turned and fired over to 1B. Ended the game. That was the highlight of my career on the hill.